Examples are not proofs.
Consider the following problem.
For any
, prove that
In case you forgot, the absolute value of a real number
A notable property of the absolute value is that it is always non-negative (positive or zero).
Proof (wrong!): Let
So the proposition is true. Let
So the proposition is also true. In either case, the proposition is true. Proved! ■
What is exactly wrong with this "proof"? It is that it only proves the cases when
Proof (correct): Let
(Recall that
If
In either case, the proposition is true. ■
In this proof,
Comments
Post a Comment